Magicianly Reviews

Working with Emiel for 4 years

I ve been working with Emiel and his team for almost 4 years now I can t begin to express how happy we are to have them help us with our brand Kidskin com They re not just an email agency they are a true partner and have helped us with great recommendations on our site and our brand Truly good people and very professional Highly highly recommend

Super responsive agency delivering great results

I ve been working with Magicianly for the last 4 months and I have nothing but great words for them Our results have grown significantly and I feel confident in their ability to grow them even more An added benefit is that they re super responsive very attentive and overall nice people to do business with Highly recommended

Fantastic Results

I am very impressed with the results that Magicianly delivered for us The quality of the work is one of the best I ve seen from an agency And this is not just on the look of the emails flows but on the substance too as they truly understood my brand and also understood how do develop copy to connect with our customer base The service is fantastic too the platforms they use to connect with us are easy to use and they are always reachable for questions comments Highly recommend

I rarely if ever write negative reviews but I had to write this one

As a small business owner myself I am very sensitive to the effect a negative review can have so I rarely if ever post one This is different My experience with Emiel Dingemans the owner of Magicianly was so egregious I felt that I had to post a review to save others from the very upsetting experience I had It became clear within days of beginning to work with him that he had no respect for my opinions and sought to impose his will on me no matter what I thought And despite my taking the time to provide him with the extensive information about my business he requested the first emails he designed for me made it clear that he had not read any of it Further he did not do the copy audit he promises to do in his sales presentation In that presentation he claims that his designers are top notch but they are not Their skills are average - no better than what I create in Canva and I am not a professional designer The multiple communication tools he requires clients to use are cumbersome and add no value Given all of this I fired him within days knowing that he had misrepresented himself and that he had no respect for me as a client But since I had already paid him for the month I was forced to continue working with him His services are very expensive and I could not afford to walk away from the money I paid So I thought I would just get through the month and hopefully get some benefit in my Klaviyo performance I could not have imagined how bad things would get He taunted and bullied me repeatedly I don t use these words lightly and have kept our entire Slack conversation as evidence Every day I dreaded what might be awaiting me in that Slack thread I was so relieved when the month ended And as for the results They were not worth the upset and time I had to spend reviewing and asking for edits A short- lived increase in Klaviyo revenue mostly in response to a rare sale I authorized him to offer Now I know that it would have been better to take inspiration from a well known brand and create the emails and flows myself which is what I am doing now I see it is not as difficult as I thought This is what I recommend for other small businesses Update The response from Emeil tells you everything you need to know about him My LinkedIn profile shows how much everyone who has worked with me has enjoyed the experience And I will be editing his emails They are not working as he claims It sounds like he has put himself on my email list surreptitiously but he has no access to my account to monitor attributed sales

The best email agency we ve ever used

We have been working with Magicianly for about 4 months now and can honestly say our expectations have been exceeded in terms of execution creativity and results With other agencies we ve worked with the process of revising and approving draft mails was a serious pain With Magicianly they have expertly latched onto our brand voice and done an amazing job creating authentic emails that rarely need revision We are continually impressed and highly recommend Emiel and his team to other ecomm brands THANK YOU Magicianly

Our search for the perfect agency is finally over

Our experience with Magicianly has been phenomenal We are very particular about how we want to present our brand and in the past we have always struggled to find an agency that was able to do so in a way that we felt like was up to our standards and in our natural voice From the start Magicianly got us and all campaigns and flows have required almost no edits - which is huge and has literally never happened before with anybody that we have worked with We are very grateful to have them be a part of our team and we couldn t recommend them more highly

I ve been using Magicianly s email

I ve been using Magicianly s email marketing services for over 3 years and I can confidently say they re best agency I ve worked with Several of my business contacts also rely on them with fantastic results Their team is not only professional but also super helpful always going the extra mile to ensure we re maximizing our email campaigns If you re serious about getting the most out of your email marketing I highly recommend giving Magicianly a try

You re in good hands with Magicianly

I ve vetted many email agencies and experienced the failures and wasted money so you don t have to Thank God for finding these guys I have been working with Magicianly for exactly 1 year now They have a full team that s on top of everything related to email and sms making it so incredibly easy to work with them and actually yielding returns They are also insanely professional and it reflects in the way they have made my brands look Definitely recommend for busy business and e-commerce companies 100