If you're searching for Thrifty car rental reviews to decide on your next road trip or airport pickup, you're not alone. As a budget-friendly option under the Hertz umbrella, Thrifty promises affordable rates and straightforward rentals. But with thousands of customer experiences across platforms, the reality is mixed—leaning toward caution. Drawing from verified reviews on sites like Trustpilot, ConsumerAffairs, and TripAdvisor, this guide breaks down the good, the bad, and practical tips to rent smarter. Whether you're eyeing a compact at San Diego Airport or an SUV for a Hawaiian getaway, here's an honest overview based on real traveler feedback.
Overall Ratings: A Snapshot of Customer Sentiment
Thrifty's reputation varies by platform, but low scores dominate, highlighting issues with fees and service. Here's a quick comparison:
These ratings reflect a budget brand's trade-offs: low prices attract value-seekers, but service hiccups frustrate many. On Reddit, users call it "Russian roulette" for fees but reliable for basic needs if you book wisely.
Pros: Where Thrifty Shines
Not all feedback is doom and gloom. Travelers who prioritize savings often walk away satisfied, especially with these highlights:
-
Affordable Pricing and Value: Many snag deals under $200/week, far below competitors like Hertz. Reddit renters praise it as a "legit budget option" comparable to Alamo or Dollar, with no major breakdowns over hundreds of miles. On Rentalcars.com, 78% rate it as "reasonable value for money."
-
Vehicle Condition: Cars are often new (0-2 years old) and clean, per frequent users. One TripAdvisor reviewer got a "reasonably new Ford Escape" at San Diego Airport, and Reddit echoes this for models like Toyota or Hyundai. Rentalcars.com scores it 8.5/10 for condition.
-
Efficient Processes in Some Spots: Quick online check-ins and drop-offs earn nods—9.3/10 on Rentalcars.com. Positive outliers include friendly staff at Broome Airport (Australia) or Lincoln (UK), with seamless pickups under 10 minutes.
Experienced renters (like those on Reddit with 10+ trips yearly) say sticking to major airports and avoiding peak holidays minimizes risks.
Cons: Common Pitfalls and Red Flags
The bulk of Thrifty car rental reviews flag systemic issues, especially for first-timers. These patterns emerge across sites:
-
Hidden Fees and Billing Nightmares: Overcharges for fuel (despite full returns), tolls, or "admin" fees are rampant—e.g., $90 toll penalty or $1,000+ surprise add-ons. One ConsumerAffairs user saw a $682 quote balloon to $1,377 for four days. Refunds? Often a battle, with ignored emails.
-
Aggressive Upsells and Insurance Drama: Staff push pricey "Super Cover" despite your credit card or travel policy—adding $150+ at counters. Reddit warns of commission-driven pressure; skip it if covered elsewhere, but verify state rules (e.g., California).
-
Long Waits and Availability Woes: Airport lines stretch 1-2 hours, with reserved cars handed to walk-ups or simply unavailable—especially late nights or holidays. At Honolulu, high-mileage, dented cars topped complaints (1.3/5 average).
-
Customer Service Struggles: Rude reps, unhelpful managers, and glitchy support plague reviews—e.g., denied refunds for flight delays despite confirmations. On X (formerly Twitter), users vent about "scam" deposits and unresolved disputes.
Location matters: San Diego sees mixed waits but quick resolutions; Jacksonville Airport draws "bad review" flak for overbooking.
Location-Specific Insights
-
San Diego Airport: Expect crowds and upsell pressure, but vehicles hold up. One manager credited erroneous fees on-site—a rare win.
-
Honolulu, Hawaii: Avoid if possible—smelly, damaged cars and surprise violation charges months later (1.3/5).
-
Jacksonville, FL (Road Trips): Holiday overbooking risks high; switch to Alamo for loyalty perks.
-
Australia (e.g., Broome): Better odds for friendly service and upgrades, per local reviews.
Tips for a Smoother Thrifty Rental
As a travel writer who's analyzed hundreds of rental reviews, here's expert advice to sidestep pitfalls:
-
Book Direct or via Reputable Aggregators: Use Rentalcars.com for better rates and priority; avoid third-party sites that deprioritize you.
-
Decline On-Site Insurance Wisely: Rely on your credit card (e.g., Chase Sapphire) or personal policy—saves $300+ per trip. But document everything with photos.
-
Join Blue Chip Loyalty: Free upgrades and line-skipping at airports.
-
Fuel and Fees Check: Opt for full-to-full policy; inspect for pre-existing damage immediately.
-
Timing Matters: Arrive mid-morning; avoid holidays. If no car, demand a "walk" to Hertz (same parent company).
For alternatives, consider Enterprise for service or Turo for peer-to-peer savings, as X users suggest.
Final Verdict: Worth the Risk for Budget Travelers?
Thrifty car rental reviews paint a polarized picture: great for savvy, low-expectation renters chasing deals, but a headache for those valuing seamless service. With 75+ years in business, it's authoritative in affordability, but trustworthiness dips on transparency. If your trip's tight on budget, go in eyes-wide-open—it's often "cheap for a reason." For peace of mind, compare quotes on multiple sites.
Have your own Thrifty story? Share in the comments—we update based on fresh feedback.
Sources
Also Read