If you are trying to watch Hulu from outside the US or need a region-locked iTunes card, Mygiftcardsupply.com is often one of the first search results. The site promises "100% Genuine Codes" and "Fast Digital Delivery" for major brands like Amazon, Binance, and PlayStation.
However, buying digital codes online is high-risk. Recent investigations reveal a complex reputation: while the site has been operating for over a decade, it has been banned from displaying ratings on Trustpilot due to guideline breaches. In this review, we analyze the conflicting trust scores, the "ID verification" panic reported by Reddit users, and the truth behind their safety ratings.
Overview
Mygiftcardsupply.com is an online vendor established in 2012. Their business model revolves around selling digital gift cards to global customers, allowing users to bypass regional restrictions (e.g., buying a US Spotify card while living in Europe).
The homepage boasts a "10k+ Real Reviews" badge and claims a "4.9" rating on Trustpilot. This claim is currently under dispute. Our investigation found that Trustpilot has actively flagged the company for misleading behavior, creating a major discrepancy between their marketing and reality.
What Customers Say
User feedback is a mix of successful transactions and severe anxiety regarding the site's anti-fraud measures.
The Positive Reviews
-
RatingFacts: The site holds a 4.46-star rating ("Good Rating") based on 41 reviews, with users generally satisfied with the service.
-
Sitejabber: It holds a 3.2-star rating, with 68% of reviewers recommending the business. While not perfect, this suggests a majority of customers receive their goods.
The Trustpilot Ban (Major Red Flag)
Despite the homepage displaying a Trustpilot logo, the actual Trustpilot profile displays a "Warning" badge. Trustpilot states: "This company's rating is unavailable due to a breach of our guidelines" and notes that the company is "displaying Trustpilot content in a misleading way". This strongly suggests the "10k+ reviews" claim on their site may be inflated or manipulated.
The "ID Verification" Panic
A recurring complaint on Reddit involves the site asking for photo ID after purchase.
-
The Experience: One user described a panic-inducing experience where, after paying via PayPal, they were asked to upload an ID. Fearing a scam, they refused.
-
The Outcome: The user received a full refund because they did not provide the ID.
-
Community Context: Experienced users on Reddit explain that this is a standard (albeit annoying) practice for gift card sites to prevent credit card thieves from laundering stolen money.
Expert Analysis and Trust Indicators
We audited the website using multiple cybersecurity tools to see if the technical backend matches the user complaints.
-
ScamAdviser: Gives the site a high Trust Score of 89/100 ("Very Likely Safe").
-
Positives: Valid SSL, old domain (registered in 2012), popular traffic rank, and "friendly payment methods" (refunds available).
-
Negatives: Offers high-risk cryptocurrency services and anonymous payment methods.
-
-
ScamDoc: Paints a darker picture with a 33% Trust Score ("Poor").
-
It penalizes the site for having "Negative reviews detected on the Internet" and hidden ownership details.
-
-
Domain Legitimacy: The domain
mygiftcardsupply.comwas registered on August 23, 2012, and is paid for until 2032. Scammers rarely register domains for 20 years, indicating this is a long-term, legitimate business operation.
Mygiftcardsupply Trust Score Table
| Authority / Tool | Trust Score | Verdict |
| ScamAdviser | 89 / 100 | Very Likely Safe |
| Trustpilot | SUSPENDED | Warning: Breach of Guidelines |
| ScamDoc | 33% | Poor |
| Sitejabber | 3.2 / 5.0 | Average |
| RatingFacts | 4.46 / 5.0 | Good Rating |
Pros and Cons Table
| Pros | Cons |
| ✅ Longevity: In business since 2012 with a domain registered until 2032. | ❌ Trustpilot Penalty: Profile suspended for misleading content/guideline breaches. |
| ✅ Refunds Confirmed: Reddit users confirm receiving refunds if they decline ID verification. | ❌ Intrusive Verification: Frequently demands Photo ID after payment, which scares many customers. |
| ✅ High Security Score: Rated 89/100 by ScamAdviser for technical safety. | ❌ Mixed Reviews: ScamDoc rates it poorly (33%) due to negative feedback volume. |
Is Mygiftcardsupply.com Safe? Final Verdict
Verdict: LEGITIMATE BUT HAS COMPLIANCE ISSUES
Mygiftcardsupply.com is not a phishing scam, but it operates with strict anti-fraud policies that can feel aggressive to new users.
The evidence confirms that the company actually delivers codes and issues refunds if a transaction fails. Their domain history (2012–2032) proves they are a stable business entity, not a fly-by-night operation.
However, you should proceed with caution regarding their reputation. The fact that Trustpilot has removed their rating for violating guidelines is a serious warning sign that they may have been manipulating reviews or misrepresenting their reputation. Additionally, you must be prepared to upload a photo ID to prove you are the owner of your credit card/PayPal account.
Recommendation:
-
Expect verification: Only use this site if you are comfortable uploading your ID.
-
Check alternatives: If you want to avoid ID checks, look for official retailers first (e.g., Amazon, localized stores).
-
Don't trust the on-site stars: The "5-star" graphics on their homepage are not currently supported by the live Trustpilot profile.
FAQ
Q: Why does Mygiftcardsupply ask for my ID?
A: This is a fraud prevention measure. Because gift cards are "high risk" (easy to resell instantly), the site wants to ensure the person buying the card is the actual owner of the credit card/PayPal account, not a hacker using stolen details.
Q: Is Mygiftcardsupply a scam if they ask for verification?
A: No. As confirmed by Reddit users, if you refuse to provide ID, the site typically issues a full refund within a few days. A true scam would keep your money and ghost you.
Q: Why is there a warning on their Trustpilot?
A: Trustpilot has flagged the company for a "breach of guidelines" and for displaying Trustpilot content in a "misleading way." This usually happens when a company fakes reviews or misuses the Trustpilot logo on their own website.
Sources
-
Trustpilot – MyGiftCardSupply Warning Profile
-
ScamAdviser – Security & Trust Report
-
ScamDoc – Digital Trust Rating
-
Sitejabber – Consumer Reviews
-
RatingFacts – Authentic User Experiences
-
Mygiftcardsupply.com – Homepage Claims
-
WHOIS – Domain Registration Data
