© 2025 Rating Facts. All rights reserved.
Reviews
3.58
5-star
43.8%
4-star
14.6%
3-star
12.41%
2-star
14.6%
1-star
14.6%
Filter
Recommended
Verified
Claimed
Reviews are labeled verified when a company automatically invites people to write a review using Trustpilot’s supported invitation methods.
Rosella Nelson
N/A
1 year ago
Very good quality
Very good quality was worried about the fit since the consumer is responsible for the cost of sending them back That I wasn t happy about but glad it worked out Very good quality and comfort I would buy again Thankful for all the reviews which helped in me deciding to buy them
Keith Garner
N/A
1 year ago
Love the shoes
The shoes fit and felt great Ordered 2 pair LOVE THEM
Jim Loney
N/A
1 year ago
Comfortable and stress free
The shoes turned out to be exactly as advertised and I have received positive comments from others on how they look The fit is good and being able to get them with extra width was helpful It s hard to find comfortable dress shoes and equally stressful buying online but these shoes are both comfortable and the process is stress free
Reader Nikolas Herren
N/A
1 year ago
Great shoes
I ordered waited about 2 weeks then received my most complemented on pair of shoes I have ever worn They are comfortable and attractive Even kids come up to me and say they like them I am a satisfied customer
CHANDLERS
N/A
1 year ago
Good value and very comfortable
I really happy with my shoes The durablity I will have to see about in time but they are so comfortable I wear them all day for work as a hairdresser so I m stood for a lot of time Mine are blue and look great It took a few weeks to get them maybe just over 2 but I was busy and did not notice that much although I was kean to get them and for the price perfect I ve seen the reviews but I m happy with mine and I think they warranted 5 stars for price style and comfort there was a smell when I opened the box but that disappeared in minutes I never noticed it again
Joseph Wilder Mpa
N/A
1 year ago
Easy ordering
Easy ordering but tracking and shipping was slow and difficult Shoes are comfortable enough but the advertised wide box isn t very wide Still trying to get it to stretch out
Burton Scott
N/A
1 year ago
Just received my reorder from the
Just received my reorder from the Gatsbyshoes co they look great fit well very comfortable client care was fabulous in my return now I am stepping in comfort style
Mike
N/A
1 year ago
Power of comfort
Well initially I saw one of my customers wearing Gatsby I loved the look he told me they are the most comfortable shoe he has worn in years So I had to try easy ordering easy wearing Love every second wearing Gatsby I will be ordering again very soon I am passing my experience yo my colleagues across Canada Thank You
Lina Lamesa
N/A
1 year ago
Wide fitting should be receiving them today or
I should be receiving them today or tomorrow but these are the second pair I am purchasing This time for my son Gatsby is offering something new and different with its smart classy look in a very light and comfortable style What interested me most was it came in a wide fitting That s why I have come back to purchase the second pair
Raynard Ceaser
N/A
1 year ago
Compliments Galore
Compliments coming from everywhere Men and women asking me where I got these shoes And these are the most comfortable shoes I ve ever owned Awesome job Gatsby